December 16, 2012
Dear Mr. President,
Let me begin by saying how tremendously, awfully, and achingly sorry I am for the tragedy your country suffered on December 14, 2012. Words, simply, could not adequately come close to the horror every single person on the planet is feeling for your country at this time.
With that said, though, there is a world here, watching, for whom simple offers of condolence are not enough; and these offers are too familiar. There will be those that say this is not the time for 'politics', or perhaps will say any dialogue about anything other than how to help that community heal itself is 'opportunistic'.
Those people are wrong.
And so, let me also say, enough is enough. You are in a position found very rarely in history; empowered as an individual to make real and lasting change. You have the ability, more than any one person in the United States, to make a change to your country that will stop the disgusting regularity of these horrors.
Your country faces a number of challenges, and those of us outside of America are quite aware of your fiscal cliffs and economic crisis. But you are facing a much more grave crisis, sir, and I believe, unfortunately, you have lived within the 24-hour cable news feedback loop, the polemic body politic and in a culture that places citizenship in a land of the 'free' as sacrosanct for too long. It has left you unable to see that much more important issues need to be addressed.
Your country's children are being slaughtered.
To do anything less than make your primary and, perhaps, only priority to reduce if not remove this reality from your country is morally and, arguably, legally, wrong. You have the ability to intercede, and possibly prevent future tragedies like this one. You can count on an inevitable future tragedy, it is a certainty, if the culture of gun ownership in the United States does not change.
And it is to you, sir, to lead this change. Because you can. You can change the gun culture in America.
And you must.
While it may be that I sit outside of the realities of 'Beltway' politics, and the incredibly complex lobby structure of your three 'houses' of democracy, I would offer a few suggestions.
1. Open the debate, and let no one sit on a political or public committee with any direct financial gain to be had from what is decided. Having the NRA at the table for these discussions is akin to giving people who think the moon landing was faked access to NASA's appropriations committee. Let the debate be this; Which constitutional right is considered inferior to the right to bear arms? Life? Liberty? Freedom of speech? To move freely? To communicate with the world? To practice one's religion? For all of those rights were superseded by the 2nd amendment on Dec. 14, 2012. And if any of these rights are considered to be superior to the 2nd amendment, then they ought to be secured, in the name of the constitution, with stronger gun control laws.
2. Limit ammunition. Let no civilian-owned gun, regardless of its potential, hold more than five bullets. Make it the law of the land. Follow with a law that does not allow guns to be reloaded by their owners. Lock guns, so that registered gun shops or police stations are the only places where a gun can be reloaded. Place biometric locks on all guns, allowing only their owner to use them. Place the onus on the gun manufacturers to pay for these changes, and make liable all gun manufacturers for the crimes committed by their guns that have not been adapted to this standard. I would suggest $100 million per minor who dies as a starting point...even though it ought to be much, much higher.
3. Semi-automatic weapons should never be owned by civilians. There is nothing about a firearm that should be even partially 'automatic'. The guns used on Dec. 14, 2012 were used to their full potential. Their potential being to fire quickly, effortlessly and easily reloaded again. Any gun that advertises its value by the speed which it can end human lives is grotesque. Provide six months of grace for all guns to be brought in and converted or exchanged, at no cost to the legal owners. Those who have not converted their firearms would be subject to criminal and civil penalties.
4. Offer amnesty to those who own guns illegally. For every gun turned in, offer one semester of free tuition at a post-secondary institution of their choice. Turn guns into something useful; an education and hope.
5. Finally, ask Ted Nugent to move to any country that has more permissive gun laws than the United States. I believe Afghanistan, a selection of first world African countries and the Philippines are probably his best bet. The advantages of this last suggestion are much broader than the issue of gun control, as I'm sure you'll agree.
What do gun owners lose with these suggestions? It says nothing of what kinds of guns they can own and if they really need to compensate for whatever their phallic limitations, they can still buy an Uzi (although simply driving a Hummer is probably just as effective). Self-defense? If you haven't protected your property or person after firing off five rounds, it takes a remarkably optimistic belief in statistical improbability to think shots six through twelve are going to get the job done. How many shots are needed by a hunter to take down a nice deer, moose or bear? How much more effective are hunters or those in the act of self defense going to be if they have to manually cycle the action of their gun before they can fire again? And most importantly, how many children's lives are worth the inconvenience of these rules? This is a rhetorical question for you, but I would suggest anyone against these measures to put their answer in writing.
Just because the 'right' to bear arms exists in your constitution, it does not define what these 'arms' can do. If one were to be entirely literal with this constitutional amendment, the arms beared would have to be at the same technological level as when the amendment was written. I would suggest that muskets, on this basis, are given an exemption to any of the above rules.
There are other rights, such as the simple right of personal security; not to be killed. There are rights that are unwritten; that children should not have to fear for, or lose, their lives when they're attending a class in elementary school. And while not wanting to be either too brutal or too saccharine, children who have been gunned down in their elementary school have a right to expect their own silenced freedom of speech to be taken up by a proxy of those who can provide at least their memories with justice and change.
Nothing written here will bring back those who died on Dec. 14, 2012. Or at Columbine. Or Virginia Tech. Or Westroads Mall, or Northern Illinois University, or the Tucson Safeway, or Aurora, Colorado. Or any of the dozens of others.
But depending on what you do now, and tomorrow, and next week and through the balance of your term, you can at least slow down the horrific rate at which similar tragedies are added to this shameful list.
I think I'm probably coming from a perspective that represents a majority of people outside of the United States, and it's not solely a perspective of disbelief and disgust at how easily America proffers freedom as its badge of honour at the cost of so many lives lost due to the idea of 'freedom' being bastardized as equivalent to owning a gun.
I think it also represents the feelings of many more American voters than polls or lobbyists let on.
It's also a perspective of hope. What I know of the United States is that it is a country of dreamers, and decency, and a land where the pursuit of what's right is known to be worth sacrificing for. Americans I know and meet are good, decent, hard working and honourable people. Yours is a country with so much, and so many look at with envy. It is a destination for those who seek simple happiness. It is held up as the pinnacle, by so many people across the world, of where dreams can be realized, where fairness is entombed in its governing bodies and a life of safe, simple dreams is available for the simple cost of hard, honest work.
And the world, I believe, is in your corner. It and so many of your fellow citizens are quietly hoping against hope that you end this sick addiction to such a simplistic understanding of freedoms and rights.
So please, realize yours is a unique position.
You can do this.
Yes, you can.
Let me begin by saying how tremendously, awfully, and achingly sorry I am for the tragedy your country suffered on December 14, 2012. Words, simply, could not adequately come close to the horror every single person on the planet is feeling for your country at this time.
With that said, though, there is a world here, watching, for whom simple offers of condolence are not enough; and these offers are too familiar. There will be those that say this is not the time for 'politics', or perhaps will say any dialogue about anything other than how to help that community heal itself is 'opportunistic'.
Those people are wrong.
And so, let me also say, enough is enough. You are in a position found very rarely in history; empowered as an individual to make real and lasting change. You have the ability, more than any one person in the United States, to make a change to your country that will stop the disgusting regularity of these horrors.
Your country faces a number of challenges, and those of us outside of America are quite aware of your fiscal cliffs and economic crisis. But you are facing a much more grave crisis, sir, and I believe, unfortunately, you have lived within the 24-hour cable news feedback loop, the polemic body politic and in a culture that places citizenship in a land of the 'free' as sacrosanct for too long. It has left you unable to see that much more important issues need to be addressed.
Your country's children are being slaughtered.
To do anything less than make your primary and, perhaps, only priority to reduce if not remove this reality from your country is morally and, arguably, legally, wrong. You have the ability to intercede, and possibly prevent future tragedies like this one. You can count on an inevitable future tragedy, it is a certainty, if the culture of gun ownership in the United States does not change.
And it is to you, sir, to lead this change. Because you can. You can change the gun culture in America.
And you must.
While it may be that I sit outside of the realities of 'Beltway' politics, and the incredibly complex lobby structure of your three 'houses' of democracy, I would offer a few suggestions.
1. Open the debate, and let no one sit on a political or public committee with any direct financial gain to be had from what is decided. Having the NRA at the table for these discussions is akin to giving people who think the moon landing was faked access to NASA's appropriations committee. Let the debate be this; Which constitutional right is considered inferior to the right to bear arms? Life? Liberty? Freedom of speech? To move freely? To communicate with the world? To practice one's religion? For all of those rights were superseded by the 2nd amendment on Dec. 14, 2012. And if any of these rights are considered to be superior to the 2nd amendment, then they ought to be secured, in the name of the constitution, with stronger gun control laws.
2. Limit ammunition. Let no civilian-owned gun, regardless of its potential, hold more than five bullets. Make it the law of the land. Follow with a law that does not allow guns to be reloaded by their owners. Lock guns, so that registered gun shops or police stations are the only places where a gun can be reloaded. Place biometric locks on all guns, allowing only their owner to use them. Place the onus on the gun manufacturers to pay for these changes, and make liable all gun manufacturers for the crimes committed by their guns that have not been adapted to this standard. I would suggest $100 million per minor who dies as a starting point...even though it ought to be much, much higher.
3. Semi-automatic weapons should never be owned by civilians. There is nothing about a firearm that should be even partially 'automatic'. The guns used on Dec. 14, 2012 were used to their full potential. Their potential being to fire quickly, effortlessly and easily reloaded again. Any gun that advertises its value by the speed which it can end human lives is grotesque. Provide six months of grace for all guns to be brought in and converted or exchanged, at no cost to the legal owners. Those who have not converted their firearms would be subject to criminal and civil penalties.
4. Offer amnesty to those who own guns illegally. For every gun turned in, offer one semester of free tuition at a post-secondary institution of their choice. Turn guns into something useful; an education and hope.
5. Finally, ask Ted Nugent to move to any country that has more permissive gun laws than the United States. I believe Afghanistan, a selection of first world African countries and the Philippines are probably his best bet. The advantages of this last suggestion are much broader than the issue of gun control, as I'm sure you'll agree.
What do gun owners lose with these suggestions? It says nothing of what kinds of guns they can own and if they really need to compensate for whatever their phallic limitations, they can still buy an Uzi (although simply driving a Hummer is probably just as effective). Self-defense? If you haven't protected your property or person after firing off five rounds, it takes a remarkably optimistic belief in statistical improbability to think shots six through twelve are going to get the job done. How many shots are needed by a hunter to take down a nice deer, moose or bear? How much more effective are hunters or those in the act of self defense going to be if they have to manually cycle the action of their gun before they can fire again? And most importantly, how many children's lives are worth the inconvenience of these rules? This is a rhetorical question for you, but I would suggest anyone against these measures to put their answer in writing.
Just because the 'right' to bear arms exists in your constitution, it does not define what these 'arms' can do. If one were to be entirely literal with this constitutional amendment, the arms beared would have to be at the same technological level as when the amendment was written. I would suggest that muskets, on this basis, are given an exemption to any of the above rules.
There are other rights, such as the simple right of personal security; not to be killed. There are rights that are unwritten; that children should not have to fear for, or lose, their lives when they're attending a class in elementary school. And while not wanting to be either too brutal or too saccharine, children who have been gunned down in their elementary school have a right to expect their own silenced freedom of speech to be taken up by a proxy of those who can provide at least their memories with justice and change.
Nothing written here will bring back those who died on Dec. 14, 2012. Or at Columbine. Or Virginia Tech. Or Westroads Mall, or Northern Illinois University, or the Tucson Safeway, or Aurora, Colorado. Or any of the dozens of others.
But depending on what you do now, and tomorrow, and next week and through the balance of your term, you can at least slow down the horrific rate at which similar tragedies are added to this shameful list.
I think I'm probably coming from a perspective that represents a majority of people outside of the United States, and it's not solely a perspective of disbelief and disgust at how easily America proffers freedom as its badge of honour at the cost of so many lives lost due to the idea of 'freedom' being bastardized as equivalent to owning a gun.
I think it also represents the feelings of many more American voters than polls or lobbyists let on.
It's also a perspective of hope. What I know of the United States is that it is a country of dreamers, and decency, and a land where the pursuit of what's right is known to be worth sacrificing for. Americans I know and meet are good, decent, hard working and honourable people. Yours is a country with so much, and so many look at with envy. It is a destination for those who seek simple happiness. It is held up as the pinnacle, by so many people across the world, of where dreams can be realized, where fairness is entombed in its governing bodies and a life of safe, simple dreams is available for the simple cost of hard, honest work.
And the world, I believe, is in your corner. It and so many of your fellow citizens are quietly hoping against hope that you end this sick addiction to such a simplistic understanding of freedoms and rights.
So please, realize yours is a unique position.
You can do this.
Yes, you can.
No comments:
Post a Comment