January 3, 2015
So…the International Olympic Committee has now changed the name of one of its events. Boxing is now known as “Dating Ghomeshi”. *CUE RIMSHOT*
You know, when the Jian thing started, I was going to rant about it, but then thought…naw…I don’t want to open myself up to all the incredibly over-the-top, bullshit ‘how dare thee’ overreactions it was inevitably going to encounter. Because, you know, I hate to be confrontational.
But now we’re doing this all over again with Bill Cosby, and you know something? Fuck it. 2015 can be the year of living dangerously.
Let me be clear on one thing. I think it’s quite possible both Ghomeshi and Cosby are evil motherfuckers who’s sexual proclivities gravitate towards violence and sexual assault. I also think violence against women is an all too common thing, and we as a species will make our greatest strides only when crimes by male monsters against women are distant memories.
I also believe, however, that no one human right supersedes any other human right. And I believe, as do a few others, including crackpot organizations such as the United Nations, Amnesty International and the Red Cross, that the universal declaration of human rights is not to be cherry picked but rather needs to be considered as a whole. And in this case, I would say that Article 11 of the international declaration of human rights seems to be given a bit of a short shrift.
Article 11, you ask? Oh, you know, the one about due process and innocent until proven guilty. Proven. In a court. Court of law. Not court of public opinion.
The irony of the situation is twofold. First off, the fact the outcry of the masses against these two comes through stories proliferated in the media...when media attention (as well as potential backlash from masses getting their backs up from media stories) is the principle reason why many of the women refused to go through the process of laying formal charges in the first place. So the inspiration for the anger is also responsible for the anger. Nice.
The second part of the irony is the following. What percentage of the people railing against Cosby and/or Ghomeshi were also up in arms about Guantanamo Bay? Because, frankly folks, pick a fuckin' side. Either you’re for due process or you’re fucking well against it. You’re not for it, with the exception of certain celebrities you dislike because of something you saw on Entertainment Tonight.
And so, as some of you get ready to rear up and let loose with the righteous indignation, let me remind you all of the following…
For human rights to have any value at all, if there is any point to the idea of inalienable human rights, then they are most important when evoked for the hard cases, not just the easy ones.
The right to free speech isn't just about protecting the speech we agree with. It’s most important when protecting the voices of Fred Phelps, or David Duke, or Dan Murray of Immigration Watch.
Why? Because those ignorant fucking pricks deserve protection? No. Because equality is hard and human rights are for all humans…including the ignorant fucking pricks. And the right to a presumption of innocence and a fair trial is not solely reserved for the innocent.
Frankly, our society has become so titillated with the celebrity freak show circuit we have to continually be aware of our own sexual peccadillos as they become more voyeuristic and less grounded in anything other than a masturbatory celebration of fame and infamy. For every single person who knows of or watched the Brittany Spears crotch-shot getting out of the car, or the Pamela and Tommy Lee video or Prince Harry’s dick or whatever.
You don’t think that to be an invasion of sorts? A kind of sexual voyeurism apparently acceptable solely because it’s on Youtube or cable TV? Frankly, if you participate in the celebratory celebrity salaciousness, do you really think you are untainted?
You’re not. When we participate in that shit, when it attracts our attention in such huge numbers… with our retweeting and ‘liking’ and posting this or that and so on… our giving those stories such a ridiculous amount of attention is the fucking problem as much as anything else. Stop, already. After all, it’s the attention which leads to victimized, non-celebrity women deciding they’re not going to report these crimes to authorities.
And here’s the thing. When that happens, if the decision is made not to press charges…Then the story ends. If you don't press charges...that's it. Story over. I'm sorry. It doesn't mean it didn't happen. It doesn't mean you shouldn't be able to access all of the requisite assistance to help you recover. But...you can't go around anonymously accusing people through media outlets. And actually, even if you do reveal your identify, you can’t have judge and jury hold court through the Toronto Star or the Huffington Post. Or at least, if you do, that doesn't equate to guilt.
You can't undercut another's human rights because yours were. Period.
And we, as the audience, need to stop fucking listening to the media stories. If the universal human right to having a fair and open trial to determine one’s guilt is set aside because, well, there were a lot of people saying it…and because it’s on the news…and there were a million tweets…and a friend said they heard a guy in a bar say…and…
And fuck off.
We can make opinions. Hell, as I said, I think it likely Jian and Bill are monstrous, fucking assholes. But, the key is…likely. Not beyond a reasonable doubt. Not, in front of a jury of their peers with evidence provided to establish both guilt or innocence.
No. None of that. And that right…to a fair trial and a chance to defend oneself is just as sacrosanct as any other right.The day we as a society stop giving a flying fuck about the lives of celebrities outside of the narrow scope of their professional work is the day where women won’t have to worry about their reputations being destroyed in the ‘twitterverse’ because they pressed charges against a vicious animal who assaulted them and who happens to be on television.
And before we go too far down the road of “You have no idea how awful the criminal justice system is for victims of sexual abuse…” Yes, I have a fairly good idea. And that is a separate issue. If we want to rejig the court system to prevent lawyers from bullying and attacking victims, then do so through an open, democratic process of reform. In the meantime, the presumption of innocence and right to a fair trial is the rule of fucking law. You want to get rid of the rule of law? Well, alright, but in doing so, assault suddenly ceases to be a crime.
Oh, sorry, you just want to suspend some rules of law. And just certain human rights. Sometimes. Got it.
We do not, in this world, live within a set of rules and rights that is perfect. Sometimes, the assholes of the world get a pass because, as the saying goes, there but for the grace of god go I. Jian has been charged, and we’ll see where things stand after that process runs its course. Maybe ‘the Coz’ will too. And, like O.J. and many others, we may not be happy with the outcome. But the principle is 'better a hundred guilty men go free...'
Besides, as soon as the story has run for a week or so…we’ll all forget about it and forget about the victims. Think I’m wrong? In the past year, how often have you thought about the Sandy Hook Elementary school kids that were gunned down, and the total failure of the USA to bring forward meaningful gun control laws in the meantime? Riiiiiiight.
Jian can go fuck himself. Of that I’m certain. And the cool thing is, if he actually did, he’d probably get the beating of a lifetime. I just don’t need to see it on Twitter.
No comments:
Post a Comment